What is the role of the American Dream in F. Scott Fitzgerald's “This Side of Paradise”?

From Conflict to Identity: Main Issues Explored in US Literary Education - Ievgen Sykalo 2026

What is the role of the American Dream in F. Scott Fitzgerald's “This Side of Paradise”?

entry

Entry — Contextual Frame

"This Side of Paradise" as a Generational Document

Core Claim F. Scott Fitzgerald's debut novel, This Side of Paradise (1920), functions as a crucial coordinate system for understanding the American youth's search for meaning in the immediate aftermath of World War I, when inherited ideals of success and morality began to collapse.
Entry Points
  • Semi-Autobiographical Narrative: Fitzgerald drew heavily on his own experiences at Princeton and his early romantic pursuits, imbuing Amory Blaine's journey with an authentic, if idealized, reflection of the author's own generational anxieties. For instance, Amory's early intellectual ambitions and social climbing at Princeton mirror Fitzgerald's own aspirations during his college years.
  • Post-War Disillusionment: The novel captures the specific psychological rupture caused by World War I, as the trauma of the conflict rendered traditional Victorian values and aspirations for a stable future largely irrelevant for young Americans. This is evident in Amory's shifting moral compass and his inability to find lasting purpose in established institutions.
  • Jazz Age Genesis: Published in 1920, the novel anticipates and helps define the hedonistic and experimental spirit of the Jazz Age, portraying the nascent shift from rigid social codes to a culture of liberated self-expression and material pursuit. The vibrant, often chaotic, social scene in New York, particularly the parties and relationships Amory experiences, exemplifies this cultural transformation.
  • Critique of Privilege: Amory's privileged background and elite education are presented not as guarantees of success, but as a foundation for his specific brand of disillusionment. His inherited advantages, such as his family's wealth and access to exclusive social circles, ultimately fail to equip him for the moral and economic complexities of the modern world, leading to his eventual financial struggles and existential void.
Think About It How does Amory Blaine's early idealism at Princeton, shaped by a pre-war sensibility, specifically set him up for the unique forms of disillusionment he faces later in the shifting social landscape of New York?
Thesis Scaffold F. Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise (1920) uses Amory Blaine's early intellectual and social ambitions at Princeton to demonstrate how inherited notions of success were rendered obsolete by the cultural shifts of the Jazz Age, leading to a complex interplay between his romantic idealism and the era's cynical materialism.
psyche

Psyche — Character as System

Amory Blaine: The Performance of Identity

Core Claim Amory Blaine's identity is less a fixed self and more a series of performances, constantly adapting to perceived ideals of success and intellectual fashion, yet consistently revealing an underlying emotional and spiritual emptiness.
Character System — Amory Blaine
Desire To be admired, to possess beauty and intellect, and to find a "meaningful place" in a world he believes is destined for him, often manifested through his pursuit of women like Isabelle Borgé and Rosalind Connage.
Fear Of mediocrity, of being irrelevant, and of emotional vulnerability that might expose his lack of genuine conviction or stable self.
Self-Image As a brilliant, charming, destined-for-greatness aesthete and intellectual, a "personage" rather than merely a person, particularly during his Princeton years.
Contradiction His intellectual curiosity often serves his social climbing, and his romantic idealism clashes with his cynical observations of wealth and human nature, as seen in his simultaneous attraction to and critique of Rosalind Connage's materialism.
Function in text To embody the generational struggle to define self-worth and purpose in a rapidly changing, materialistic society that offers no stable moral compass, reflecting the "lost generation" sentiment.
Psychological Mechanisms
  • Narcissistic Projection: Amory frequently projects his own romanticized ideals onto women like Isabelle Borgé and Rosalind Connage, allowing him to experience love as an extension of his own self-image rather than a genuine connection to another person. His infatuation with Rosalind, for example, is deeply intertwined with her social status and perceived perfection.
  • Intellectual Drifting: His engagement with various philosophies, from socialism to Catholicism, serves less as a genuine search for truth and more as a series of intellectual poses. Each phase, such as his brief flirtation with socialist ideas, offers a temporary framework for his evolving identity without demanding deep, consistent commitment.
  • Performative Cynicism: Amory adopts a detached, cynical posture towards society and relationships, particularly after his experiences in New York and his failed engagement to Rosalind. This allows him to mask his vulnerability and the profound disillusionment that follows his failed aspirations, presenting himself as above the fray.
Think About It To what extent is Amory's profound disillusionment a direct consequence of external societal failures, and to what extent is it a product of his own internal, shifting desires and inability to commit to a stable identity?
Thesis Scaffold Amory Blaine's recurring pattern of intense infatuation followed by cynical detachment, particularly evident in his relationships with Rosalind Connage and Eleanor Savage, reveals how his self-image is constructed through external validation rather than internal conviction, ultimately leading to an existential void.
world

World — Historical Pressure

The Jazz Age as a Shaping Force

Core Claim The Jazz Age in F. Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise (1920) is not merely a chronological setting but an active, transformative force, shaping and ultimately eroding the traditional values and aspirations Amory Blaine inherits.
Historical Coordinates 1917: The United States enters World War I, disrupting traditional social structures and accelerating cultural change, particularly among the youth who experienced the war's trauma, influencing Amory's sense of purpose. 1919: The Volstead Act initiates Prohibition, paradoxically fueling illicit glamour, speakeasy culture, and a rebellious youth movement that rejected established moral codes, which Amory encounters in New York. 1920: This Side of Paradise is published, capturing the immediate post-war mood and the nascent Jazz Age, making it a foundational text for understanding the era's cultural shifts and Amory's personal trajectory within them.
Historical Analysis
  • Post-War Hedonism: The widespread disillusionment following World War I manifests in the characters' pursuit of pleasure and superficiality, as the trauma of war made traditional moral frameworks seem irrelevant or hypocritical. Amory's participation in lavish parties and his transient romantic affairs exemplify this "live for today" mentality.
  • Rise of Consumer Culture: The burgeoning American economy and advertising industry created new aspirations for material wealth and social status, particularly in New York. These external markers, such as expensive clothes and exclusive social events, offered a tangible, if ultimately hollow, definition of success for a generation seeking new forms of validation, which Amory initially embraces.
  • Shifting Gender Roles: The emergence of "New Woman" figures like Rosalind Connage and Eleanor Savage challenges Victorian expectations of female domesticity and passivity. Their independence, assertiveness, and open sexuality reflect broader societal changes in women's roles and expectations in the public and private spheres, directly impacting Amory's romantic ideals and experiences.
Think About It How do the specific historical shifts of the early 20th century, such as the end of WWI and the onset of Prohibition, directly influence Amory's personal trajectory and his evolving, often contradictory, understanding of the American Dream?
Thesis Scaffold Fitzgerald's depiction of Princeton's rigid social hierarchy and New York's vibrant parties in This Side of Paradise (1920) illustrates how the economic boom and cultural rebellion of the Jazz Age created a new, unstable definition of the American Dream, one built on fleeting material gain rather than enduring moral principle, thereby shaping Amory Blaine's disillusionment.
craft

Craft — Recurring Elements

The Corrosive Allure of Wealth

Core Claim Fitzgerald uses recurring symbols of wealth, glamour, and superficiality not as mere descriptive elements, but to trace the corrosive effect of materialism on Amory Blaine's initial idealism and his eventual disillusionment.
Five Stages of a Motif
  • First appearance: The "glittering things" Amory desires as a young man, particularly the social prestige associated with Princeton and debutante balls, initially represent the pinnacle of success and the promise of a charmed life. He is drawn to the superficial splendor of the elite.
  • Moment of charge: Rosalind Connage, described as "the most expensive and desirable of all," embodies the fusion of love and material aspiration. Her allure is inseparable from her wealth and social standing, making her the ultimate prize in Amory's pursuit of the American Dream, as he seeks to possess both her and the lifestyle she represents.
  • Multiple meanings: The constant parties and social gatherings, initially symbolizing youthful exuberance and freedom, gradually reveal themselves as sites of emotional emptiness and moral decay. What begins as a quest for connection and excitement, such as the New York social scene, devolves into temporary distraction and superficial interaction rather than genuine fulfillment.
  • Destruction or loss: Amory's financial ruin and Rosalind's marriage to a wealthier man, Dawson Ryder, mark the collapse of his material aspirations. These events force him to confront the fragility of dreams built on external validation and the transactional nature of Jazz Age society, stripping away his illusions of effortless success.
  • Final status: The "lost generation" motif, with Amory walking alone at the novel's end, suggests that the pursuit of the Jazz Age's symbols ultimately leads to a profound sense of isolation and a search for an undefined "something." The superficial glamour leaves a void, prompting Amory's final, ambiguous declaration of self-knowledge.
Comparable Examples
  • Green light — The Great Gatsby (Fitzgerald, 1925): a distant, unattainable symbol of a past ideal, corrupted by wealth and memory.
  • Valley of ashes — The Great Gatsby (Fitzgerald, 1925): a physical manifestation of the moral decay underlying the pursuit of the American Dream.
  • The "golden bowl" — The Golden Bowl (Henry James, 1904): a beautiful but flawed object symbolizing the hidden imperfections within seemingly perfect relationships and social facades.
Think About It If Fitzgerald had described the parties and social events in This Side of Paradise with less emphasis on their opulence and more on genuine human connection, how would Amory's journey of disillusionment be fundamentally altered?
Thesis Scaffold The recurring motif of "glittering" social events and "expensive" women in This Side of Paradise (1920) functions as a critical commentary on how the Jazz Age's material excess ultimately hollows out Amory Blaine's romantic and intellectual aspirations, demonstrating the era's corrosive impact on personal identity.
ideas

Ideas — Philosophical Stakes

Idealism in Collision with Materialism

Core Claim This Side of Paradise (1920) argues that the American Dream, when pursued through superficial means and external validation, inevitably leads to a profound disillusionment that strips away both inherited values and personal identity.
Ideas in Tension
  • Romantic Idealism vs. Cynical Realism: Amory's early belief in grand love and intellectual pursuits clashes with the transactional nature of relationships and the pursuit of wealth he observes in New York society. The text demonstrates that genuine connection, such as his initial hopes for a profound love with Rosalind, is often sacrificed for social or material gain, leading to his eventual cynicism.
  • Inherited Morality vs. Modern Hedonism: The lingering Victorian moral codes, represented by figures like Monsignor Darcy, are directly challenged by the unrestrained pursuit of pleasure and self-gratification characteristic of the Jazz Age. The novel portrays a generation, exemplified by Amory and his peers, actively rejecting traditional constraints without finding a new ethical framework, leading to moral ambiguity.
  • Self-Discovery vs. Social Performance: Amory's quest for an authentic self is constantly undermined by his desire to conform to fashionable intellectual and social roles. His identity becomes a series of adopted personas, such as his brief intellectual phases or his attempts to fit into various social circles, rather than an organic development rooted in conviction, leaving him with a sense of emptiness.
In The Crack-Up (1936), F. Scott Fitzgerald himself reflects on the psychological toll of living through an era of intense material aspiration and subsequent economic collapse, offering a meta-commentary on the very disillusionment depicted in his early work, This Side of Paradise (1920).
Think About It Does Amory's final declaration of knowing himself, "I know myself, but that is all," represent a genuine moment of self-awareness and acceptance, or is it merely another intellectual pose in his ongoing, unresolved search for identity?
Thesis Scaffold Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise (1920) critiques the inherent contradictions within the early 20th-century American Dream by juxtaposing Amory Blaine's initial romantic idealism with the cynical materialism he encounters, ultimately arguing that such a dream leads to an existential void rather than fulfillment.
essay

Essay — Thesis Development

Crafting Arguments for "This Side of Paradise"

Core Claim Students often struggle to move beyond summarizing Amory Blaine's journey, failing to articulate how Fitzgerald's narrative choices critique the American Dream rather than just describe its effects.
Three Levels of Thesis
  • Descriptive (weak): "Amory Blaine experiences disillusionment as he grows up in the Jazz Age, losing his idealism."
  • Analytical (stronger): "Fitzgerald uses Amory Blaine's failed relationships and financial struggles to illustrate the superficiality of the American Dream in This Side of Paradise (1920)."
  • Counterintuitive (strongest): "By depicting Amory Blaine's intellectual and social fluidity as a form of self-erasure, F. Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise (1920) argues that the Jazz Age's promise of boundless self-invention ultimately leads to a profound loss of identity rather than liberation."
  • The fatal mistake: Students often focus on Amory's personal failures as character flaws rather than as symptoms of a larger societal critique, missing how Fitzgerald uses his protagonist to expose the inherent emptiness of the era's dominant aspirations and the flawed nature of the American Dream itself.
Think About It Can someone reasonably disagree with your thesis statement, or are you simply stating a fact about the novel's plot or themes? If it's a fact, it's not an argument.
Model Thesis Through the recurring motif of Amory Blaine's intellectual and romantic reinventions, F. Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise (1920) demonstrates that the Jazz Age's emphasis on external validation and material success paradoxically undermines the very self-discovery it purports to offer, leading to a nuanced critique of the era's values.


S.Y.A.
Written by
S.Y.A.

Literature educator and essay writing specialist. Over 20 years of experience creating educational content for students and teachers.