Literature Reviews - 2025

Comprehensive Review of Yolk by Mary H.K. Choi

Introduction

Yolk by Mary H.K. Choi is a deeply emotional and introspective novel that explores themes of sisterhood, identity, mental health, and self-destruction. Unlike typical young adult (YA) novels, it leans more into the new adult category, tackling raw and difficult topics with unflinching honesty. The novel follows two estranged Korean-American sisters—Jayne and June—who are unexpectedly forced back into each other’s lives when June is diagnosed with cancer. Through their complex and often messy relationship, Yolk examines the intricacies of family bonds, self-worth, and the struggles of growing up.

Plot Overview

Jayne Baek, a 20-year-old fashion student in New York City, is barely holding her life together. She’s struggling financially, involved in an unhealthy relationship, and battling an eating disorder that she refuses to acknowledge. Meanwhile, her older sister June appears to have everything—a high-paying finance job, a luxurious apartment, and a seemingly perfect life. However, when June is diagnosed with uterine cancer, she reaches out to Jayne after years of estrangement.

Faced with the harsh realities of their past and present, the sisters are forced into an uneasy cohabitation. Their relationship is fraught with resentment, miscommunication, and unresolved childhood traumas, yet their forced proximity brings moments of tenderness and understanding. As they navigate the challenges of June’s illness, Jayne is also confronted with her own struggles—body dysmorphia, anxiety, and a desperate need for validation.

Yolk is not just a story about sisterhood but also about survival, self-destruction, and ultimately, healing.

Strengths of the Novel

1. A Raw and Honest Portrayal of Mental Health
   Choi does not romanticize eating disorders or mental health struggles. Instead, she presents them in their full, uncomfortable reality. Jayne’s bulimia is not just a subplot—it’s an omnipresent struggle that shapes her self-image and relationships. The depiction of therapy, shame, and recovery is nuanced, making it an essential read for those who appreciate realistic portrayals of mental health.
2. Complex Sister Dynamics
   The heart of Yolk lies in Jayne and June’s relationship. Their interactions are not neatly packaged with dramatic reconciliations or sentimental moments. Instead, they argue, misunderstand each other, and struggle to express their love in ways that feel authentic. Their relationship is deeply relatable, particularly for anyone who has experienced familial estrangement or sibling rivalry.
3. A Powerful Commentary on Cultural Identity
   As Korean-American women, Jayne and June grapple with cultural expectations, body image issues, and the burden of immigrant family pressures. The novel touches on the unique experiences of Asian-American identity, particularly the internalized shame and societal pressures that shape their self-worth.
4. Choi’s Unique Writing Style
   Choi’s prose is sharp, introspective, and filled with biting humor. Jayne’s narration is filled with self-deprecating wit, making her a flawed yet deeply engaging protagonist. The writing style is highly contemporary, referencing pop culture and the social media-driven world of young adults.
5. An Unconventional Love Story
   While the novel focuses on sisterhood, there is also a subtle romance subplot between Jayne and Patrick, a former acquaintance who becomes an unexpected source of stability. Unlike typical YA romances, their relationship unfolds quietly and imperfectly, serving as a backdrop rather than the driving force of the novel.

Criticisms

1. Pacing and Structure
   Some readers found the novel to be slow in certain sections, particularly in Jayne’s introspective moments. While the character-driven approach is one of the book’s strengths, it sometimes meanders, making it feel longer than necessary.
2. Overuse of Pop Culture References
   Choi’s writing is extremely contemporary, with references to social media, fashion, and celebrities. While this makes the book feel immediate and relevant, it may also make it feel dated in the future. Readers who prefer more timeless prose might find this aspect distracting.
3. Unrealistic Elements in June’s Character
   June, at 23, is portrayed as having an ultra-successful finance career and a luxury apartment in Manhattan—something that feels somewhat implausible given her age. While this detail doesn’t significantly impact the plot, it does create a slight disconnect from reality.
4. Some Unresolved Storylines
   While Yolk excels in exploring emotions and character development, some elements—such as the sisters' relationship with their parents—are left somewhat unresolved. The ending, though fitting, does not provide a traditional sense of closure.

Impact and Significance

Yolk is a groundbreaking novel that goes beyond the typical YA or new adult experience. It captures the messiness of growing up, the weight of family expectations, and the painful process of self-discovery. The novel’s exploration of eating disorders, mental health, and cultural identity makes it an essential read for those looking for books that tackle difficult topics with honesty and care.

Conclusion: Is Yolk Worth Reading?

Absolutely. Yolk is a powerful and deeply affecting novel that lingers long after the last page. It’s not an easy read, but it is an important one, especially for those who appreciate stories about complex family relationships and mental health struggles.

This book is highly recommended for readers who:

• Enjoy character-driven stories with deep emotional impact.
• Are interested in narratives exploring sibling relationships.
• Want an honest portrayal of eating disorders and mental health.
• Appreciate contemporary fiction with a sharp, witty narrative voice.

With its raw honesty, compelling characters, and beautiful prose, Yolk is a must-read for anyone who values deeply personal, unfiltered storytelling.