Explanatory essays - The Power of Knowle: Essays That Explain the Important Things in Life - Sykalo Eugene 2025

Cross-Cultural Perspectives on the Concept of Identity in Literature
Comparative literature and cross-cultural analysis

Identity: The Big, Slippery Beast

Identity in literature is like trying to pin down a cloud with a thumbtack. It’s everywhere, it’s everything, but the second you try to define it, it shifts. I’ve been obsessed with this lately—not in a scholarly, let-me-cite-Foucault way, but in a “why does this character make me feel like I’m staring into a cracked mirror?” way. Books from different cultures tackle identity like it’s a fight they’re all destined to lose, but they swing anyway. And I love them for it.

Take The Tale of Genji, that thousand-year-old Japanese novel by Murasaki Shikibu. It’s not just a story; it’s a fever dream of courtly life, all silk robes and secret glances. Genji, the shining prince, is a walking identity crisis. He’s noble, sure, but he’s also a mess—chasing women, chasing status, chasing some version of himself he can’t quite grasp. His identity isn’t a fixed thing; it’s a performance, layered like the robes he wears, shifting with every new lover or political maneuver. In Heian-era Japan, who you are depends on who’s watching, and Genji plays that game better than anyone. But there’s this undercurrent of longing, like he knows it’s all a charade. Reading it, I felt this weird mix of awe and pity. Like, dude, you’re dazzling, but you’re drowning.

Now, jump across the globe and a few centuries to Toni Morrison’s Beloved. If Genji’s identity is a performance, Sethe’s is a wound. Morrison doesn’t just write about slavery in the American South; she makes you feel the weight of it in your bones. Sethe’s identity is tangled up in what she’s survived—her choices, her losses, the ghost of her daughter haunting her every step. When I read Beloved, I was gutted, not just by the story but by how Sethe’s sense of self is both forged and shattered by memory. Her identity isn’t a neat narrative arc; it’s a jagged line, bleeding across the pages. Morrison shows how culture—American, Black, post-Civil War—doesn’t just shape identity; it carves it with a knife.

Cultures Collide, Identities Splinter

What’s wild is how these books, worlds apart, both wrestle with identity as something external as much as internal. In Genji, it’s the court, the gossip, the rigid hierarchy of Heian Japan that tells you who you’re allowed to be. In Beloved, it’s the legacy of slavery, the white gaze, the community that both holds you up and judges you. I mean, isn’t that the truth of it? Identity isn’t just what’s in your head; it’s what the world decides to pin on you.

Let’s throw another book into the mix: Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Americanah. This one hit me like a conversation with a friend who’s too smart for their own good. Ifemelu, the Nigerian protagonist, moves to America and suddenly her identity isn’t just “Ifemelu” anymore—it’s “Black,” “African,” “immigrant.” She’s navigating race in a way she never had to back home, and Adichie writes it with this sharp, almost surgical clarity. There’s a scene where Ifemelu starts blogging about race in America, and it’s like she’s peeling back her own skin to show you what’s underneath. I was reading it on a bus, underlining like a maniac, because it felt so true. Identity, for Ifemelu, is this constant negotiation between who she was in Nigeria and who America expects her to be. And yeah, sometimes it’s funny—her takes on American hair culture are gold—but it’s also exhausting. I felt that exhaustion in my gut.

What’s fascinating (and, okay, a little infuriating) is how these books show identity as a kind of trap. Genji’s trapped by his status, Sethe by her past, Ifemelu by race and migration. But they don’t just sit there and take it. They push back, they reinvent, they survive. And isn’t that the whole deal with identity? It’s not a thing you have; it’s a thing you do. I’m sitting here, typing this, and I’m like—am I even the same person I was when I started this paragraph? Probably not.

The Mess of Being Human

Here’s where I get a little stuck. Comparing these books feels like comparing apples, oranges, and… I don’t know, a thunderstorm? They’re all grappling with identity, but the cultural lenses are so different it’s almost dizzying. In Genji, identity is fluid but constrained by ritual. In Beloved, it’s raw, visceral, tied to survival. In Americanah, it’s global, modern, shaped by borders and blogs. Yet there’s this thread running through them: the self is never just the self. It’s the world around you, the history behind you, the eyes on you.

I keep thinking about a line from Beloved where Sethe says, “Freeing yourself was one thing; claiming ownership of that freed self was another.” That line wrecked me. It’s not just about slavery; it’s about anyone who’s ever tried to figure out who they are when the world keeps trying to define them for you. Genji’s got his courtly mask, Ifemelu’s got her blog, Sethe’s got her scars. They’re all trying to claim ownership of themselves, and it’s messy as hell.

And maybe that’s what I love about literature from different cultures. It doesn’t give you answers. It gives you questions, fights, fragments. Reading these books back-to-back was like stepping into three different worlds and realizing they’re all haunted by the same ghost: the question of who you are when the world won’t stop talking.

Why This Matters Now

Okay, I’ll admit it—I’m writing this in 2025, and the world feels like it’s on fire. Not literally (well, not always), but you know what I mean. We’re all obsessed with identity right now—who gets to claim what, who’s allowed to be what, who’s canceled for saying the wrong thing about it. These books feel like they’re speaking directly to that chaos. They’re not preachy, thank God, but they’re urgent. They remind you that identity isn’t just a buzzword; it’s a battleground.

Take Americanah. Ifemelu’s story feels like it could’ve been written yesterday. The way she navigates race, love, and ambition in a globalized world—it’s like she’s living in our group chats, our headlines, our late-night spirals. And Beloved? It’s not just history; it’s a warning. The past doesn’t stay buried, and neither does the question of who gets to define you. Even Genji, ancient as it is, feels weirdly modern. The way he performs his identity, curating himself for different audiences—it’s like he’s got an Instagram account in 11th-century Kyoto.

Where Does This Leave Us?

I don’t have a neat bow to tie this up with, and honestly, I don’t want one. These books—The Tale of Genji, Beloved, Americanah—they’re not here to solve identity for you. They’re here to make you feel the weight of it, the slipperiness, the beauty and the pain. They’re from different times, different places, but they’re all asking the same question: Who are you when the world’s watching? And who are you when it’s not?

I’m sitting here, staring at my laptop, and I’m thinking about how these stories have stuck with me. Genji’s fleeting loves, Sethe’s haunted courage, Ifemelu’s razor-sharp wit—they’re all part of the same messy, human attempt to figure out what it means to be you. And maybe that’s enough. Maybe the point isn’t to pin down identity but to keep wrestling with it, across cultures, across centuries, across pages.

So, yeah. Go read these books. Get mad, get sad, get obsessed. Let them mess you up a little. They’re worth it.