French Literature Reviews - 2026
B. Fondane, Lévy-Bruhl ou le métaphysicien malgré lui
Philosophy, Anthropology and Ideas
Benjamin Fondane
Lévy-Bruhl ou le métaphysicien malgré lui
text edited and introduced by Serge Nicolas and Dominique Guedj
éd. de l'Éclat
October 2019
ISBN : 978-2-84162-454-6
336 pages
Price: 19 €
The writings of Lucien Lévy-Bruhl (1857–1939) played a pivotal role in the fields of sociology and anthropology during the first half of the 20th century, yet the philosophical dimension of his work has often been underestimated. In a lengthy, previously unpublished manuscript from the 1940s, Benjamin Fondane revisits this thought, offering an interpretation that extends far beyond the boundaries Lévy-Bruhl set for himself. He perceives it as a dramatic "turn of events" that shakes up all our preconceived notions, outlining a "metaphysics of knowledge" that bridges the gap between rationality and mysticism, and relegating Aristotelian logic to the rank of merely one logic among others. What Fondane
aims for is a form of knowledge that persuades rather than compels humanity—a knowledge liberated from the Aristotelian "logical hell" and finally receptive to the "revelations" of life itself. He delivers a philosophical testament of paramount importance, though the man-made hell he would later face denied him the opportunity to bring it to completion.
The text is preceded by a Notice by Michel Carassou, a Preface by Serge Nicolas, a Note on the Text by Monique Jutrin, and followed by an Afterword by Serge Nicolas.
View the book on the publisher's website…
*
An article on this work can be read on en-attendant-nadeau.fr:
"Let's not topple the statue of Lévy-Bruhl", by Pascal Engel (published online July 29, 2020)
At a time when toppling statues of colonialists and denouncing alleged racists has become commonplace, one might fear for that of the great anthropologist Lucien Lévy-Bruhl, often remembered solely for his now-infamous concept of "primitive" or "pre-logical" mentality. Following a long period of neglect, his theories have been reassessed. However, they had already been the subject of highly original analyses by Benjamin Fondane, whose own work has likewise been rediscovered. Consequently, we now have a second statue worth preserving.
Lucien Lévy-Bruhl held a prominent position in early twentieth-century French social science, particularly through his investigations into comparative mentalities and the foundations of anthropological thought. His reception has frequently oscillated between sociological orthodoxy and philosophical critique, as scholars sought to define the precise relationship between empirical ethnology and theoretical reason. Within intellectual history, these debates touch upon enduring questions concerning the universality of cognitive categories and the methods appropriate for studying diverse human cultures. Readers interested in the intersections of modern philosophy and early anthropological theory may find this volume relevant.
Benjamin Fondane approaches these themes through an unpublished manuscript that presents a distinctive reading of Lévy-Bruhl's intellectual trajectory. The text highlights a philosophical dimension within the anthropologist's work, connecting rational inquiry with broader metaphysical concerns. Scholars of twentieth-century French literature and philosophy have increasingly examined Fondane's critical output, which frequently engaged with the tensions between modern rationality and existential experience. This edition provides access to a previously unavailable text, accompanied by scholarly framing that situates the manuscript within the wider context of both authors' intellectual legacies.