French Literature Reviews - 2026
A. Honneth, A World of Disruption: Critical Theory, Psychoanalysis, Sociology
Philosophy, Anthropology and Ideas
Review published in Acta Fabula (February-March 2015, vol. 16, no. 2): "Understanding Suffering at Work: Philosophy & Sociology" by Patricia Desroches.
***
Axel Honneth, A World of Disruption: Critical Theory, Psychoanalysis, Sociology
Pierre Rusch (Translator), Olivier Voirol (Preface)
Paris: La Découverte, "Théorie critique" series, 2013.
EAN: 9782707158574
299 p.
Publisher's presentation:
Contemporary social developments have made the fragmentation of society a central issue. Since Marx, critical theory has developed practical potentials for emancipation beyond social divisions by critiquing capitalist modernity. The Critical Theory of the Frankfurt School, with which Axel Honneth is associated, has made the link between social fragmentation and emancipation one of its key themes.
Here, he offers an innovative reading that reveals its inherent tensions, providing an analysis of its various authors (Horkheimer, Adorno, Benjamin, Marcuse, Fromm), its precursors (Rousseau, Lukács), and thinkers who can be associated with or echo it (notably Bourdieu, Lévi-Strauss, Foucault, Adorno, Habermas, and Castoriadis). Axel Honneth examines their works through a reading that is always mindful of clarity and rigor.
His concept of the "struggle for recognition" is thus reflected in these theoretical discussions, offering a glimpse of the prominent role of French social philosophy in his own philosophical project. Furthermore, responding to a series of objections, Axel Honneth engages with the Freudian legacy of his Critical Theory predecessors to promote a concept of recognition drawing on interactionist psychoanalysis.
Finally, the critical contributions of the normative concept of recognition are reaffirmed, both by questioning the emancipatory potential of work today and by exploring contemporary forms of social critique.
Table of Contents:
THE ORIGINS OF A TRADITION OF THOUGHT
The Logic of Emancipation: The Philosophical Legacy of Marxism
Work and Instrumental Action: Categorical Problems of a Critical Theory of Society
A World of Disruption: The Underground Relevance of Lukács's Early Work
THE TRANSFORMATIONS OF CRITICAL THEORY
Max Horkheimer's Original Idea: The Sociological Deficit of Critical Theory
Critical Theory: From the Center to the Periphery of a Tradition of Thought
A Divided Rationality: The Motifs of an Anthropology of Knowledge in the Frankfurt School
PSYCHOANALYSIS AND CRITICAL THEORY
The Work of Negativity: A Psychoanalytic Revision of the Theory of Recognition
The Facets of the Presocial Self: A Reply to Joel Whitebook
THE RELEVANCE OF CRITICAL THEORY TODAY
Work and Recognition: An Attempt at Redefinition
The Difficult Task of Preserving a Tradition: On the Future of the Institute for Social Research
The Theory of Justice as an Analysis of Society: Reflections on Hegel
* * *
An article about this book can be read on the website nonfiction.fr:
"Disruption, Recognition, and Emancipation," by C. Ruby.
And on laviedesidees.fr:
This collection situates Axel Honneth within the rich intellectual tradition of the Frankfurt School, tracing its evolution from early Marxist critiques of capitalist modernity to contemporary sociological inquiries. Rooted in the German philosophical heritage initiated by Kant and Hegel, critical theory seeks not merely to interpret society but to evaluate its emancipatory potentials. Honneth engages deeply with foundational figures such as Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno, and Walter Benjamin, while also establishing dialogues with prominent French thinkers like Pierre Bourdieu and Michel Foucault, bridging diverse traditions in modern social philosophy.
The volume offers valuable insights for students and scholars of sociology, philosophy, and political theory grappling with contemporary issues of social fragmentation and the changing nature of labor. By integrating psychoanalytic perspectives and refining his renowned concept of the struggle for recognition, Honneth addresses urgent questions regarding justice and alienation in the modern workplace. Readers interested in the ongoing relevance of Frankfurt School critique and the future trajectories of critical social research will find this collection an essential guide.