Top 100 Literature Essay Topics - Ievgen Sykalo 2026
The use of foreshadowing in “Of Mice and Men” by John Steinbeck
The Naturalist Trap
Determinism and the Mechanical Precision of the Play-Novella
In Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck utilizes the compressed structure of the play-novella to argue that the American Dream is a structural impossibility. Through the lens of Naturalism—the belief that heredity and environment dictate human destiny—Steinbeck uses foreshadowing not as a tool for suspense, but as a demonstration of Environmental Determinism. By mirroring the "mercy killing" of Candy’s dog with the eventual death of Lennie Small, Steinbeck suggests that in a predatory economic landscape, the vulnerable are systematically "weeded out" by a society that values utility over humanity.
The Luger and the Logic of Utility
The introduction of Carlson’s Luger P08 in Chapter 3 is the novella's primary application of Chekhov’s Gun. Carlson’s insistence on shooting Candy’s dog—an animal no longer capable of "pulling its weight"—establishes the "utility-first" morality of the ranch. When George later uses the same German military pistol to end Lennie’s life in Chapter 6, he is not committing a crime of passion, but fulfilling a debt of fraternity. This act realizes Candy’s regret: “I ought to of shot that dog myself... I shouldn’t ought to of let no stranger shoot my dog” (Chapter 3). By shooting Lennie himself, George preserves the "tragedy of fraternity" rather than allowing him to die in terror at the hands of the search party.
Fact: The tragedy is Mechanically Determined. In Chapter 1, George instructs Lennie to hide in the brush by the river "if you jus' happen to get in trouble." By defining the escape route before any crime is committed, Steinbeck confirms that Lennie's failure is an inevitable byproduct of his Naturalistic makeup—his child-like mind trapped in a powerful body.
The Motif of "Soft Things": A Scale of Violence
Steinbeck utilizes a Pattern of Escalating Violence to track Lennie’s tactile obsessions. In Chapter 1, it is a dead mouse; in Chapter 3, the backstory of the "red dress" in Weed; in Chapter 5, a puppy. This culminates in the death of Curley’s wife, who is visually defined by danger-adjacent "red" motifs: shoes with ostrich feathers and red fingernails. Her death is not a choice but a biological certainty in a world that offers no protection for Lennie’s unique cognitive needs. Steinbeck underscores this with the finality of the death scene.
“Lennie jarred, and then settled slowly forward to the sand, and he lay without quivering.” (Chapter 6)
Why it sticks: The phrase "without quivering" is the ultimate structural echo. It mirrors the stillness of the dead animals earlier in the novella, completing the Naturalist argument: Lennie has been reduced to the same biological status as the small things he accidentally destroyed.
Socio-Economic Futility
While George recites the dream of the farm "like a story" (Chapter 6), characters like Crooks provide the Socio-Economic Reality. Crooks notes that he has seen "hunderds of men" with the same dream, but "never a God damn one of 'em ever gets it" (Chapter 4). This skepticism grounds the foreshadowing in the 1930s reality of Migrant Disposability. The "dream" was never a possibility; it was an anesthetic for men already caught in the "Naturalist Trap" of the Great Depression.
To identify Parallel Structure, look for an event in the first half of a work that mirrors the climax. If an author spends time describing a specific way an animal is put down (like Carlson's dog), and a similar death occurs later (Lennie), you are looking at Thematic Anchoring. Ask: "How does the author use the first death to justify the ethics or necessity of the second?"
If the world is "Naturalistic"—meaning our lives are decided by our biology and surroundings—does that make Carlson the most "honest" character for accepting that the weak must be discarded? Or is George's struggle to protect Lennie the only thing that makes them human in a predatory world?
- Intro: Naturalism and the environment—Why the end was decided in Chapter 1.
- Section 1: The Pattern of Softness—Tracing the tactile escalation from Weed to the Ranch.
- Section 2: The Dog and the Gun—Parallelism as a tool for moral justification.
- Section 3: Crooks and the Dream—Socio-economic skepticism as a reality check.
- Conclusion: "Without Quivering"—The finality of the biological verdict.
Literature educator and essay writing specialist. Over 20 years of experience creating educational content for students and teachers.