Top 100 Literature Essay Topics - Ievgen Sykalo 2026
The use of imagery in “Their Eyes Were Watching God” by Zora Neale Hurston
The Mule and the Blossom
Ecofeminism, Sexual Awakening, and the Structural Limits of the Horizon in Their Eyes Were Watching God
In Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God, Janie Crawford’s journey from a "silenced object" to a "sovereign subject" is mapped through the tension between the Pear Tree and the Mule. By examining her movement from the sexual awakening in Chapter 2 to the internalized agency of the final horizon in Chapter 20, we see a novel that argues for Subjective Sovereignty. Hurston uses Free Indirect Discourse to ensure that Janie's internal "blossoming" carries the same narrative weight as the external world that attempts to stifle it.
The Pear Tree: A Model for Reciprocity
Janie’s moral and erotic baseline is established in Chapter 2 under a blossoming pear tree. The image of the "dust-bearing bee sink into the sanctum of a bloom" is not a romantic cliché; it is a model for Organic Reciprocity. This vision is immediately challenged by Nanny’s declaration that "de nigger woman is de mule uh de world." While Nanny seeks "protection" through wealth and property, Janie seeks a human equivalent to the pear tree—a relationship that mirrors the effortless, mutual harmony of the natural world.
Her subsequent marriages to Logan Killicks and Joe Starks represent the "Mule" side of this dichotomy. Logan treats Janie as agricultural capital, while Joe treats her as a static ornament, famously forcing her to hide her Hair under a headrag to suppress her identity and communal power. It is only when Janie releases her hair (Ch. 13) that she begins to reclaim the pear tree's promise.
The Hurricane: Naturalism and Spiritual Reckoning
The climax in Chapter 18 shifts the novel from social drama to Cosmic Naturalism. As Janie and Tea Cake huddle in the dark, "their eyes were watching God." This is a spiritual acknowledgment of the limits of human agency. Unlike the pathetic fallacy, where nature reflects human emotion, Hurston’s hurricane is indifferent to the characters' desires. This forces Janie into a state of Existential Reckoning, where her survival is no longer dependent on a husband, but on her own resilience against a world that is often brutal and unpredictable.
"The monster began to roll in his bed... They sat in company with the others in other shanties, shivering in the sleepless and terrible night. Their eyes were watching God." (Ch. 18)
Why it sticks: This moment strips away Janie's social status, her wealth in Eatonville, and her reliance on Tea Cake, leaving only her raw capacity to endure. It marks her transition from "watching men" to "watching God."
The Horizon: Memory and the Frame Narrative
The novel is a Frame Narrative, beginning and ending with Janie telling her story to Pheoby Watson. By Chapter 20, the "horizon" that men chase like ships at a distance (Ch. 1) has been internalized. Janie describes "pulling in her horizon like a great fish-net." She carries the garden seeds Tea Cake bought for her, not as a symbol of her own "fruiting," but as a memorial to the love that allowed her to find her voice. She has mastered her history, weaving her grief into her identity.
Conclusion: The Sovereign Voice
Ultimately, Hurston proves that Janie Crawford is a survivor of both social and cosmic storms. She returns to Eatonville not to change the town, but to inhabit her own story. As noted by critics like Henry Louis Gates Jr., Janie's voice is her ultimate victory. She proves that while society may try to make a woman a "mule," her interior life remains a "blossom" that can never be fully contained. She has finally reached the horizon, only to find it was within her all along.
Literature educator and essay writing specialist. Over 20 years of experience creating educational content for students and teachers.