Explanatory essays - The Power of Knowle: Essays That Explain the Important Things in Life - Sykalo Eugene 2025

Cross-Cultural Perspectives on the Concept of Heroism in Literature
Comparative literature and cross-cultural analysis

Heroes Are Messy, and So Are We

Let’s start with Achilles. The guy’s a walking disaster, right? In The Iliad, he’s this bronzed, sulky war machine, dragging Hector’s body around like it’s performance art. He’s not “heroic” because he’s noble; he’s heroic because he’s too much—too angry, too proud, too heartbroken over Patroclus. The Greeks didn’t want their heroes to be perfect; they wanted them larger than life, flaws and all. I mean, who hasn’t wanted to burn it all down because someone broke their heart? Achilles feels like he could be one of us, if we were, y’know, mythical and had a goddess for a mom.

Now, jump to Japan, and you’ve got Prince Genji from The Tale of Genji. This guy’s not out there slaying monsters or dragging corpses. He’s a courtier, a poet, a guy who’s basically a professional at longing. His heroism isn’t about brawn; it’s about how he navigates a world of fragile beauty, where a misplaced poem or a snubbed lover can ruin you. Genji’s a hero because he feels everything—love, regret, the fleetingness of it all—and still keeps going. He’s not larger than life; he’s painfully, exquisitely in it. Comparing him to Achilles is like comparing a thunderstorm to a slow-burning candle. Both are captivating, but they’re playing different games.

What’s wild is how these two heroes—Achilles with his rage, Genji with his melancholy—reflect what their cultures valued. The Greeks were all about glory, the clash of swords, the epic flex. Japan, at least in the Heian period, was obsessed with refinement, with the art of being human in a world that’s slipping away. It’s not that one’s better; it’s that they’re asking different questions about what makes a hero. Do you fight fate, or do you lean into it? Do you conquer, or do you endure?

The Internet’s Obsessed with Heroes, Too

Okay, let’s fast-forward to now, because I’m not here to just nerd out over old texts. Scroll through X, and you’ll see we’re still obsessed with heroes, even if we don’t always call them that. Think about the way people stan characters like Paul Atreides in Dune or Katniss Everdeen in The Hunger Games. Paul’s this messianic figure, half savior, half tragedy, carrying the weight of a whole galaxy’s expectations. Katniss? She’s just trying to survive, but her defiance turns her into a symbol. They’re modern spins on heroism, but they’re still grappling with the same questions: What do you owe the world? What do you owe yourself?

Now, let’s throw in a curveball: Sundiata, the hero of the West African epic Sundiata: An Epic of Old Mali. This guy’s story is oral, passed down through griots, and it’s got this raw, communal energy you don’t get in written texts. Sundiata’s not just a warrior; he’s a unifier, a king who pulls a fractured empire together. His heroism isn’t about him—it’s about the people he lifts up. Compare that to, say, Katniss, who’s all about individual rebellion. Sundiata’s story feels like it belongs to everyone, like it’s woven into the soil of Mali. Katniss’s story? It’s hers, personal, jagged. Both are heroes, but one’s a collective dream, the other’s a solo scream.

I’m kinda obsessed with how these stories don’t just sit in their time periods like museum pieces. They’re alive, messy, contradictory. On X, you’ll see people arguing about whether Tony Stark’s a hero or a narcissist with a god complex. Spoiler: he’s both. That’s the point. Heroes aren’t one thing—they’re what we need them to be, what we fear they might be, what we wish we could be.

Why Do We Even Care?

Here’s where I get stuck. Why do we keep circling back to heroes? Why do I care so much about Achilles’s temper tantrums or Genji’s love letters? Part of it’s because they’re not just characters—they’re mirrors. They show us what we value, what we’re scared of. In ancient Greece, glory was everything, so Achilles is this blazing, untouchable star. In Heian Japan, beauty was the currency, so Genji’s all about mastering the art of longing. In modern America, we’re obsessed with authenticity, so Katniss’s raw, unpolished defiance feels like catnip.

But it’s more than that. Heroes are how we make sense of chaos. Life’s a mess—wars, heartbreak, pandemics, that one tweet you regret at 3 a.m.—and heroes give us a way to imagine we can handle it. They don’t always win, but they try. And sometimes, trying’s enough. Like, take Sundiata—he’s born weak, mocked, exiled, but he comes back to build an empire. That’s not just a story; that’s a vibe. It’s hope, stubborn and sweaty.

The Dark Side of Heroes

But let’s not get too cozy. Heroes can be dangerous. Not just because they’re flawed—though, yeah, Achilles’s ego is a walking war crime—but because we project so much onto them. Look at how we treat modern “heroes” on X. One day, someone’s a saint for calling out injustice; the next, they’re canceled for a bad take from 2012. We build them up, then tear them down, like we’re playing god with their stories. It’s not new—think of how Odysseus, the clever trickster of The Odyssey, gets worshipped and vilified in the same breath. He’s a hero, sure, but he’s also a liar, a cheat, a guy who leaves a trail of bodies behind him.

This is where cross-cultural stuff gets spicy. In some cultures, heroes are allowed to be messy. Odysseus’s cunning is celebrated in Greece, but in, say, Confucian-influenced Chinese literature, a hero’s supposed to be upright, moral, a walking virtue. Take Liu Bei from Romance of the Three Kingdoms. He’s not perfect, but his heroism comes from loyalty, from sticking to his brothers through hell. Compare that to Achilles, who’d probably yeet his bros for a shot at eternal glory. It’s not just different aesthetics—it’s different moral universes.

So, What’s a Hero, Anyway?

I’m sitting here, trying to pin this down, and it’s like chasing smoke. A hero in one culture is a villain in another. Achilles is a legend to the Greeks, but to the Trojans, he’s a monster. Genji’s a romantic icon in Japan, but to a modern reader, his endless affairs might scream “red flag.” Sundiata’s a unifier, but what about the people who got trampled in his empire-building? The more you dig, the less solid it all feels.

Maybe that’s the point. Heroes aren’t answers—they’re questions. They force us to ask: What’s worth fighting for? What’s worth sacrificing? And yeah, I know I’m getting a little philosophical here, but bear with me. When I read about Achilles raging or Genji pining or Katniss shooting arrows at the system, I’m not just reading. I’m wondering what I’d do, who I’d be, in their shoes. And I bet you are too.

The World Keeps Spinning

I could keep going—there’s so much more to say about how heroes shift across cultures, how they’re shaped by everything from religion to politics to whether a society values the individual or the collective. But honestly? I’m kinda tired of trying to tie it all up. Heroes don’t fit in a box, and neither does this article. They’re messy, contradictory, beautiful, awful. They’re us, but bigger. And maybe that’s why we keep telling their stories, from ancient epics to blockbuster movies to that one X thread that’s blowing up right now.

So, go read The Iliad or Sundiata or hell, even The Hunger Games. Feel what they make you feel. Get mad, get inspired, get confused. That’s what heroes are for.